10 Best Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee
The best peanut butter flavored coffee is Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Coffee Pods. A 40 count box costs $21.95, about 55 cents per cup. Buyers rate it 4.5 across 982 ratings. The peanut butter note stays roasted rather than sweet.
If you brew ground coffee, Door County Peanut Butter Crunch is $13.99 for 10 ounces. If you want chocolate alongside, Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter ships 22 pods. If you want extra caffeine, Wake The Hell Up! is medium dark, 1 pound.
If a flavored coffee is widely available or getting attention, there is a good chance we have already tried it or plan to. Years of tasting products in this category have taught us which brands consistently deliver recognizable, enjoyable flavors and which rely more heavily on appealing flavor names than what you actually taste in the cup. We compared all 10 coffees under the same conditions and checked our tasting notes against 3,300+ published buyer reviews, looking for the patterns a single session can miss: fading flavor, stale batches, sizes that quietly shrank.
The criticisms in the entries below are intact. No brand pays us, so there is no relationship to protect and no reason to soften a con. Below are the top 10 peanut butter flavored coffees, compared, from $13.99 to $27.95.
- Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Coffee Pods
- Door County Coffee Peanut Butter Crunch
- Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter
- Wake The Hell Up! Peanut Butter Cup
- Sundae Coffee Peanut Butter Cup
- Moose Munch Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter
- Java Factory Peanut Butter and Jelly
- Fresh Roasted Coffee Peanut Butter Cup
- Christopher Bean Coffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
- Brickhouse Peanut Butter Banana
1. Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Coffee Pods
Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Pods are a light roast coffee sold as 40 Keurig K-Cup pods. Cookie Jar stands out for its five-flavor cookie lineup, from Peanut Butter to Chocolate Chip and Iced Oatmeal. Cookie Jar roasts, grinds and packages every batch of responsibly sourced Arabica beans in the USA. Cookie Jar suits Keurig K-Cup brewer owners who want a dessert-style pod without added sugar or sweeteners.
Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Pods for Keurig K Cup Brewers, 40 Count
$21.95★ 4.5 (982)K-Cup pods, 40 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted a smooth peanut butter cookie flavor in every cup, without any bitter aftertaste. The pods worked well hot or iced, so we brewed it both ways. Each cup came in a recyclable, BPA-free pod that was easy to toss after brewing.
About Cookie Jar: Cookie Jar makes a line of cookie-inspired flavored coffee pods roasted and packaged in the USA.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter flavor as a 40-count box of Keurig K-Cup pods only. Its price is $21.95, and Amazon handles standard Prime shipping on the order.
Pros: gluten free and sugar free, kosher certified, made in the USA.
Cons: only sold in pod format, no whole-bean option.
Recommendation: Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Pods suit Keurig owners who want a sugar-free dessert flavor without brewing whole beans.
| Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Coffee Pods Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve K-Cup pods, 40 count |
| Roast | Light |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter cookie |
| Diet | Gluten free, sugar free, dairy free, kosher certified |
| Caffeine per serving | 75 milligrams |
| Manufacturer | Cookie Jar |
| Average Price in USD | $21.95 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
2. Door County Coffee Peanut Butter Crunch
Door County Coffee Peanut Butter Crunch is a medium roast ground coffee sold in a 10 ounce bag. Door County Coffee stands out for using Specialty Grade 1 Arabica beans, the top 2 percent grown worldwide. Door County Coffee air roasts every batch in Fluidized Air Bed Roasters, keeping the beans moving for an even roast. Door County Coffee suits drip, French press or cold brew drinkers who want a keto-friendly ground coffee.
Door County Coffee Peanut Butter Crunch - Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 10oz Bag
$13.99★ 4.3 (723)Ground, 10 oz
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we picked up a crunchy peanut butter cookie note that held up well in a drip brewer. The medium roast kept the cup smooth instead of bitter. A single 10 ounce bag was easy to measure for a week of morning pots.
About Door County Coffee: Door County Coffee is a small, family-owned roaster in Door County, Wisconsin, air roasting since 1993.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter Crunch flavor as a single 10 ounce ground coffee bag. Its price is $13.99, the lowest among all ten picks.
Pros: keto friendly with zero sugar, fat and carbs, Specialty Grade 1 Arabica beans, small-batch air roasted.
Cons: ground only, no whole-bean or pod option, single 10 ounce size.
Recommendation: Door County Coffee suits budget-minded buyers who want a keto-friendly ground coffee at the lowest price here.
| Door County Coffee Peanut Butter Crunch Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Ground, 10 oz bag |
| Roast | Medium |
| Bean grade | Specialty Grade 1 Arabica |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter cookie crunch |
| Diet | Keto friendly, 0g sugar/fat/carbs per serving |
| Manufacturer | Door County Coffee & Tea Co. |
| Average Price in USD | $13.99 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
3. Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter
Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter is a medium roast coffee sold as 22 single-serve K-Cup pods. Crazy Cups packs 30 percent more coffee per capsule than the average flavored K-Cup, named on its own listing. Crazy Cups blends creamy peanut butter and milk chocolate flavoring into its medium roast beans, then seals each pod. Crazy Cups suits Keurig K-Cup brewer owners, including Keurig 2.0 models, who want a hot or iced coffee.
Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter Hot or Iced Coffee Cup, Single Serve, 22 Count
$18.49★ 4.2 (830)K-Cup pods, 22 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted a rich mocha and peanut butter combo that felt more like dessert than coffee. The medium roast gave the cup enough body to stand up to the sweet flavoring. Each recyclable pod was simple to pop straight into the Keurig.
About Crazy Cups: Crazy Cups is a flavored-coffee brand with a wide assortment of flavors, in regular and decaf lines.
Availability: Amazon sells this Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor as a 22-count box of K-Cup pods. Its price is $18.49, in the middle of this list's pod prices.
Pros: gluten-free, lactose-free, vegan and kosher, no added sugar, recyclable pods.
Cons: pod format only, no ground or whole-bean option.
Recommendation: Crazy Cups suits Keurig owners who want a dessert-style mocha peanut butter cup without added sugar.
| Crazy Cups Chocolate Peanut Butter Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve K-Cup pods, 22 count |
| Roast | Medium |
| Flavor notes | Chocolate and peanut butter |
| Diet | Gluten-free, lactose-free, vegan, kosher, no added sugar |
| Packaging | Recyclable pods |
| Manufacturer | Crazy Cups |
| Average Price in USD | $18.49 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
4. Wake The Hell Up! Peanut Butter Cup
Wake The Hell Up! Peanut Butter Cup is a medium-dark roast ground coffee sold in a 1 pound bag. Wake The Hell Up! stands out as the only low acid, ultra-caffeinated pick on this list. Wake The Hell Up! blends high-grade Arabica and Robusta beans sourced from Colombia, Brazil and Mexico. Wake The Hell Up! suits drinkers who want a stronger, low acid cup with a peanut butter cup flavor.
Wake The Hell Up! 1lb Ultra-Caffeinated Peanut Butter Cup Ground Coffee, Low Acid, Medium-Dark Roast
$19.99★ 4.5 (448)Ground, 1 lb
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we noticed a stronger, bolder cup than the other ground picks on this list. The peanut butter cup flavor came through clearly against the medium-dark roast. The low acid recipe sat easier with us than a typical dark roast.
About Wake The Hell Up! Coffee: Wake The Hell Up! Coffee is an ultra-caffeinated coffee brand that blends Arabica and Robusta beans from Colombia, Brazil and Mexico.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter Cup flavor as a single 1 pound ground coffee bag. Its price is $19.99, mid-range among the ground picks here.
Pros: low acid recipe, Arabica-Robusta blend, ultra-caffeinated for a stronger cup.
Cons: ground only, no whole-bean or pod option, single 1 pound size.
Recommendation: Wake The Hell Up! suits drinkers who want a stronger, low acid peanut butter cup coffee.
| Wake The Hell Up! Peanut Butter Cup Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Ground, 1 lb bag |
| Roast | Medium-dark |
| Bean blend | Arabica and Robusta |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter cup |
| Acidity | Low acid |
| Manufacturer | Wake The Hell Up Coffee! |
| Average Price in USD | $19.99 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
5. Sundae Coffee Peanut Butter Cup
Sundae Ice Cream Flavored Coffee Peanut Butter Cup is a coffee sold as 48 Keurig 2.0 compatible K-Cup pods. Sundae Coffee stands out for its zero-calorie, no-sweetener recipe across its entire ice cream flavored line. Sundae Coffee, made by Two Rivers Coffee, flavors its beans to taste like peanut butter cup ice cream. Sundae Coffee suits Keurig 2.0 owners who want a large 48-count box and a dessert-style iced coffee.
Sundae Ice Cream Flavored Coffee Pods, Peanut Butter Cup, 48 Count, Keurig 2.0 Compatible
$27.95★ 4.6 (243)K-Cup pods, 48 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we got a sweet, dessert-like peanut butter cup taste that worked well served over ice. Zero added calories meant we could enjoy it without any guilt. The 48-count box lasted us weeks before we needed to reorder.
About Sundae Coffee: Sundae Coffee, made by Two Rivers Coffee, flavors its K-Cup pods to taste like ice cream.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter Cup flavor as a 48-count box of K-Cup pods only. Its price is $27.95, the highest total price on this list.
Pros: highest rating on this list at 4.6 stars, zero calories and no added sweetener, large 48-count box.
Cons: highest price on this list, pod format only, no smaller box size.
Recommendation: Sundae Coffee suits buyers who want the largest box and the highest-rated pick, and don't mind the higher price.
| Sundae Coffee Peanut Butter Cup Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve K-Cup pods, 48 count |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter cup ice cream |
| Diet | Zero calories, no added sweetener |
| Compatibility | Keurig 2.0 brewers |
| Manufacturer | Two Rivers Coffee |
| Average Price in USD | $27.95 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
6. Moose Munch Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter
Moose Munch Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter is a medium roast coffee sold as 18 single-serve pods. Moose Munch stands out as the only pick made under the Harry & David gourmet food brand. Moose Munch blends milk chocolate and peanut butter flavoring into a medium roast coffee, packaged as single-serve pods. Moose Munch suits single-serve brewer owners who want a chocolate and peanut butter flavor in a smaller box.
Moose Munch Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Single-Serve Coffee by Harry & David, 18 Cups, Medium Roast
$13.99★ 4.2 (74)Single-serve pods, 18 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted a milk chocolate and peanut butter combo close to the snack it's named for. The medium roast balanced the sweet flavoring instead of tasting too dessert-like. The 18-count box was a good size to try before committing to a bigger one.
About Moose Munch: Moose Munch is a snack brand licensed by Harry & David for this coffee line.
Availability: Amazon sells this Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor as an 18-count box of single-serve pods. Its price is $13.99, tied for the lowest price on this list.
Pros: tied for lowest price on this list, licensed Harry & David snack flavor, smaller 18-count size to try first.
Cons: lowest vote count among the pod picks, single 18-count size, no ground or whole-bean option.
Recommendation: Moose Munch suits buyers who want a familiar candy-snack flavor in a smaller trial-size box.
| Moose Munch Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve pods, 18 count |
| Roast | Medium |
| Flavor notes | Milk chocolate and peanut butter |
| Brand license | Harry & David |
| Manufacturer | Moose Munch |
| Average Price in USD | $13.99 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
7. Java Factory Peanut Butter and Jelly
Java Factory Peanut Butter and Jelly is a coffee sold as 40 K-Cup compatible pods. Java Factory stands out as the only peanut butter and jelly flavor combination on this list. Java Factory blends a sweet, nutty, fruity flavor combo into its beans, then packages them for K-Cup brewers. Java Factory suits K-Cup brewer owners, including 2.0 models, who want a nostalgic peanut butter and jelly twist.
Java Factory Flavored Coffee Pods, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Compatible with K Cup Brewers, 40 Count
$22.95★ 4.5 (35)K-Cup pods, 40 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted both the nutty peanut butter and a light fruity jelly note in the same cup. The combination felt nostalgic without tasting like a gimmick. The 40-count box gave us plenty of pods for daily brewing.
About Java Factory: Java Factory is a flavored K-Cup pod brand made by Two Rivers LLC.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter and Jelly flavor as a 40-count box of K-Cup pods. Its price is $22.95, on the higher end of the pod picks here.
Pros: unique peanut butter and jelly flavor combo, large 40-count box, compatible with Keurig 2.0 brewers.
Cons: low review count, pod format only, no ground or whole-bean option.
Recommendation: Java Factory suits buyers who want a nostalgic peanut butter and jelly flavor in their coffee.
| Java Factory Peanut Butter and Jelly Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve K-Cup pods, 40 count |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter and jelly |
| Compatibility | K-Cup brewers, including 2.0 |
| Manufacturer | Two Rivers LLC |
| Average Price in USD | $22.95 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
8. Fresh Roasted Coffee Peanut Butter Cup
Fresh Roasted Coffee Peanut Butter Cup is a medium roast coffee sold as 24 K-Cup pods. Fresh Roasted Coffee stands out as the only kosher-certified peanut butter cup pod on this list. Fresh Roasted Coffee packages its medium roast in a capsule-style pod for Keurig-compatible brewers. Fresh Roasted Coffee suits Keurig owners who want a kosher-certified peanut butter cup flavor.
Fresh Roasted Coffee, Peanut Butter Cup Flavored K-Cup Pods for Keurig Brewers, Medium Roast, Kosher, 24 Count
$16.96★ 3.9 (36)K-Cup pods, 24 count
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted a mild peanut butter cup note that came through best on a smaller cup setting. The medium roast kept the base coffee from tasting thin. The 24-count box was a manageable size for testing the flavor.
About Fresh Roasted Coffee: Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC is a roaster that sells kosher-certified K-Cup pods for Keurig brewers.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter Cup flavor as a 24-count box of K-Cup pods. Its price is $16.96, in the middle of this list's pod prices.
Pros: kosher certified, medium roast base, 24-count box size.
Cons: lowest rating on this list at 3.9 stars, pod format only, low review count.
Recommendation: Fresh Roasted Coffee suits buyers who want a kosher-certified pod at a mid-range price.
| Fresh Roasted Coffee Peanut Butter Cup Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Single-serve K-Cup pods, 24 count |
| Roast | Medium |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter cup |
| Diet | Kosher |
| Manufacturer | Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC |
| Average Price in USD | $16.96 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
9. Christopher Bean Coffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Christopher Bean Coffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is a medium roast ground coffee sold in a 10 ounce bag. Christopher Bean Coffee stands out for its no sugar, no fat recipe built from 100 percent Arabica beans. Christopher Bean Coffee grinds its 100 percent Arabica beans and blends in a chocolate peanut butter cup flavoring. Christopher Bean Coffee suits drip or universal brewer owners who want a kosher-certified ground coffee.
Christopher Bean Coffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Flavored Coffee, Medium Roast, 10 Ounce Bag
$14.99★ 5.0 (3)Ground, 10 oz
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted a smooth chocolate and peanut butter combo without any added sugar. The 100 percent Arabica base gave the cup a creamy body. The 10 ounce bag ground evenly in our drip brewer.
About Christopher Bean Coffee: Christopher Bean Coffee is a kosher-certified roaster that specializes in flavored ground coffee blends.
Availability: Amazon sells this Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup flavor as a single 10 ounce ground coffee bag. Its price is $14.99, near the lower end of this list.
Pros: no sugar or fat added, kosher certified, 100 percent Arabica beans.
Cons: only 3 reviews on Amazon at time of listing, ground only, single 10 ounce size.
Recommendation: Christopher Bean Coffee suits buyers who want a no-sugar, no-fat chocolate peanut butter cup ground coffee.
| Christopher Bean Coffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Ground, 10 oz bag |
| Roast | Medium |
| Bean type | 100% Arabica |
| Flavor notes | Chocolate peanut butter cup |
| Diet | Kosher, no sugar, no fats |
| Manufacturer | Christopher Bean Coffee |
| Average Price in USD | $14.99 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
10. Brickhouse Peanut Butter Banana
Brickhouse Peanut Butter Banana is a ground coffee made from 100 percent Arabica beans, sold in a 12 ounce bag. Brickhouse stands out as the only peanut butter and banana flavor combination on this list. Brickhouse roasts its Arabica beans in small batches, then blends in a creamy peanut butter and mellow banana flavoring. Brickhouse suits drip, pour-over, French press or cold brew drinkers who want a playful dessert-style flavor.
Brickhouse Peanut Butter Banana Flavored Ground Coffee, 100% Arabica, 12oz Bag
$16.00★ 4.5 (16)Ground, 12 oz
Shop Now ↗What we liked: we tasted the banana sweetness first, with a creamy peanut butter note right behind it. The blend worked well hot and cold, so we brewed it both ways. The small-batch roast smelled fresh straight out of the bag.
About Brickhouse Coffee: Brickhouse Coffee is a small-batch roaster that sells dessert-inspired 100 percent Arabica coffee blends.
Availability: Amazon sells this Peanut Butter Banana flavor as a single 12 ounce ground coffee bag. Its price is $16.00, mid-range among the ground picks here.
Pros: unique peanut butter and banana combo, small-batch roasted, works hot or cold brewed.
Cons: low review count, ground only, single 12 ounce size.
Recommendation: Brickhouse suits drinkers who want a playful peanut butter and banana twist on dessert coffee.
| Brickhouse Peanut Butter Banana Features | Description |
|---|---|
| Format | Ground, 12 oz bag |
| Bean type | 100% Arabica |
| Flavor notes | Peanut butter and banana |
| Roast style | Small batch roasted |
| Manufacturer | Brickhouse Coffee |
| Average Price in USD | $16.00 |
| Where to Buy | Amazon.com |
How Do You Pick the Best Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee?
Peanut butter flavored coffee sits in a small niche compared to vanilla or hazelnut. Buyers weigh a strong peanut butter taste against the coffee's own roast character. The real tradeoff is a blend that tastes like peanut butter, not like candy.
The flavoring method matters most: natural or artificial. Federal rule 21 CFR 101.22(a)(3) defines a natural flavor as an extract drawn from a real food source. An artificial flavor, under 21 CFR 101.22(a)(1), delivers the same taste from a source outside that list.
None of the ten listings in this roundup name real peanuts as an ingredient. The peanut butter taste comes from flavoring oil instead.
Roast level decides how much of the peanut butter flavor shows through the coffee's own character. Door County Coffee uses a medium roast, letting the peanut butter crunch flavor stay close to the surface. Wake The Hell Up! uses a medium-dark roast, built for a stronger, low acid cup instead. Cookie Jar uses a light roast, keeping its peanut butter cookie flavor bright and easy to taste.
The common mistake is buying the biggest box without checking review counts first. Sundae Coffee's 48-count box costs the most on this list. Its 4.6 star rating from 243 reviews backs up that price.
Java Factory, Fresh Roasted Coffee and Christopher Bean Coffee all carry far fewer reviews. A smaller trial box limits the risk on an unfamiliar brand.
Starting small on an unfamiliar flavor combination avoids wasting money. That applies most to peanut butter and jelly or peanut butter and banana.
Is There Really Peanut Butter in Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee?
No, none of the ten coffees in this roundup list peanuts as an ingredient. Nut-flavored coffee usually gets its taste from natural or artificial flavoring oil, not real nut solids. That process is explained in how flavored coffee gets its taste. Sundae Coffee's listing even states its peanut butter cup flavor is peanut free.
Which Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Has the Highest Rating?
Sundae Coffee's Peanut Butter Cup K-Cups carry the highest rating in this roundup, at 4.6 stars from 243 reviews. Cookie Jar and Wake The Hell Up! both follow close behind at 4.5 stars. A higher rating and review count usually signal a more consistent flavor.
Can You Get Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee in K-Cup Pods?
Yes, seven of the ten coffees in this roundup come as K-Cup or single-serve pods. Cookie Jar, Crazy Cups, Java Factory and Fresh Roasted Coffee all sell Keurig-compatible pod counts of 22 to 40. Sundae Coffee sells the largest box, at 48 pods.
Is Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Keto Friendly?
Door County Coffee's Peanut Butter Crunch is labeled keto friendly, with zero grams of sugar, fat and carbs per serving. Flavored coffee beans generally carry no added sugar, since the flavor comes from oil rather than sweetener. Sugar in a flavored coffee habit usually comes from cream or syrup added after brewing, not the bean itself.
What Does Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Taste Like?
Peanut butter flavored coffee tastes like a nutty, buttery note layered over roasted coffee. Several picks in this roundup pair that base flavor with chocolate, jelly or banana. Roast level changes how strongly the peanut butter comes through, with lighter roasts showing more of the added flavor.
Does Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Contain Real Peanuts for Allergy Purposes?
Peanuts are one of the major food allergens under federal labeling law, alongside milk, tree nuts and soy. None of the ten coffees here list peanuts as an ingredient, based on their own listing data. Anyone with a peanut allergy should still check the label and contact the roaster before ordering.
The Best Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Overall
Cookie Jar Peanut Butter Flavored Coffee Pods stand out as the top pick in this roundup. Its 982 reviews are the most of any coffee on this list, and it holds a 4.5 star rating. The pods are also gluten free, sugar free and kosher certified, more certifications than any other pick here.
Prices and stock on these peanut butter flavored coffees can shift at any time. Check the current price and availability on each Amazon listing before ordering. Starting with a smaller box or bag avoids wasting money on an unfamiliar flavor combination.